Reviewers rave about beer selection at Amsterdam Ale House — does it live up to the hype?

Amsterdam Ale House holds a 4.3★ average across 1436 Google reviews, with 84% rating it 4–5 stars. What the reviews say: • Reviewers mention “beer selection” the most (105 mentions). • Listed price range: $10-40. • The praise is consistent across reviews — but does it hold up in person? Some reviewers put it plainly: • “I ate here twice on our visit since it was closest to the hotel. Both nights were really crowded, but the food came out quickly. Everyone was in their own little world, so I never struck up a conversation with anyone...” • “Nice selection of beers on tap. A tad on the expensive side. Lots of TVs for sports and the food looked great, but we didn't get anything to eat. A short walk from Central Parks Strawberry Fields.” What’s your take — does the data match your night out?