Reviewers rave about chicken pot pie at Gabby O'Haras — does it live up to the hype?

Gabby O'Haras holds a 4.4★ average across 975 Google reviews, with 86% rating it 4–5 stars. What the reviews say: • Reviewers mention “chicken pot pie” the most (8 mentions). • Listed price range: $30-40. • The reviews are unusually one-sided in its favor — the real test is your night out. In reviewers’ own words: • “We stopped here for drinks on Wed 12/27/25 4pm before our return on a bus trip to Bryant Park. This was our second visit here, short walk from Bryant Park. Found seats at the bar. Were brought our drinks & menus by fr...” • “An amazing hidden gem right by Times Square! The food is great and the staff are spectacular!! Everyone behind the bar is awesome and all of them are great to chat to. Would come back any time I am in NYC to go grab a...” Have you been? Agree or disagree — what’s your take?