Reviewers rave about chicken pot pie at Pig n Whistle — does it live up to the hype?

Pig n Whistle holds a 4.5★ average across 3058 Google reviews, with 88% rating it 4–5 stars. What the reviews say: • Reviewers mention “chicken pot pie” the most (5 mentions). • Listed price range: $10-30. • The reviews are unusually one-sided in its favor — the real test is your night out. A couple of reviewers said it best: • “This Irish pub on 36th by MSG is actually the cutest rugby bar in Manhattan and I'm a little obsessed It's warm, cozy, and the bar is lined with rugby jerseys and international flags, TVs playing every game you could...” • “Great place for drinks and food. Ample selection of different drinks and beers on hand and small but tasty menu of their fare. I had the fish and chips and left full. Fish was nicely done and a good amount. Worth a vi...” If you have an opinion, drop it below — specifics help the next person decide.